Building Wealth & Lifestyle
through St. Simons Island Real Estate
David Burton, Realtor | St. Simons Real Estate Advisor
Executive Brief Buyer and Seller Takeaway: St. Simons Island Market Update October 17, 2026
David Burton, Realtor® | Keller Williams Realty • October 17, 2026
Executive Market Takeaway
198 total ListingIds parsed verbatim yield 198 active single-family with median $1,223,500 and 109-day average DOM. 68% of inventory sits above $850K creating luxury competition. Today's activity: 3 new listings at 1 to 2 ADOM averaging $1,340,000, 4 price adjustments averaging $906,250, and 0 closed sales indicating fresh inventory entering with continued price discovery.
Buyer Takeaway
Buyers: Focus on fresh inventory at 1 to 2 ADOM like Driftwood Place $1,575,000, Yacht Club Drive $1,700,000, and Saint Clair Drive $745K for best selection. Leverage 4 price cuts today in Sapelo Street $835K, Vassar Point Drive $935K, Settlers Hammock Circle $750K, and Rice Mill $1,095K to negotiate 2 to 3 percent below list on homes over 90 ADOM.
Seller Takeaway
Sellers: With 86 homes in $850K to $1,999,999 and 49 over $2M, differentiate with waterfront YN, lot over 0.5 acres, and 2026 build status. Price within 3 percent of active comps to avoid 100+ day market time. Under $650K sellers hold leverage with only 25 competitors. Four reductions today prove pricing above $935K without waterfront leads to extended DOM.
| Single-Family Price Tier | Active Listings | Market Share |
|---|---|---|
| Under $650,000 | 25 | 13% |
| $650,000 - $849,999 | 38 | 19% |
| $850,000 - $1,999,999 | 86 | 43% |
| $2,000,000+ | 49 | 25% |
Full Daily Market Report Below
Buying or Selling a Home on St. Simons Island is a signification lifestyle and financial decision. I help $850k+ Buyers and Sellers understand the local Market, evaluate opportunities, price strategically, and negotiate from a position of knowledge.
-David Burton
Buying on St. Simons Island?
Buying on St. Simons at $850K+ is a major asset decision. Whether it's your coastal dream home, a second home, or your next investment, it's a significant move. I know how much this means, and I use real market intelligence, strategic negotiation, and local expertise to secure the right property for your goals.
— and I'll guide you through every step with clarity.
Selling on St. Simons Island?
Selling on St. Simons at $850K+ demands more than a listing. Whether it's your family home, getaway, or investment property, it's a major financial move. I know what's at stake, and I use market intelligence, market trend positioning, and strategic negotiation to secure top dollar for your unique home.
— I understand the $850K+ buyer mindset
Not Ready to Buy or Sell Yet?
That's fine. If you’re watching the St. Simons Island Market and have a question, I will point you toward the data that matters for your situation.
— I also offer Free No Obligation Property Valuations.
David Burton – St. Simons Island, Ga Realtor
David Burton, Realtor® | Market Intelligence. Justified Negotiations. St. Simons Expertise.
I am a St. Simons Island, Ga Realtor specializing in buyer representation and home sales throughout St. Simons Island.
As a real estate investor, business coach, and author of E3 to Millionaire, my role is to help buyers evaluate communities, compare neighborhoods, understand local market conditions, and make informed purchasing and sales decisions. I also guide homeowners through every stage of the selling process, from pricing and marketing to negotiation and closing.
Clientele: Professionals, executives, retirees, entrepreneurs, investors, second home buyers, 1031 Exchange, and families relocating to St. Simons Island, Georgia.
Notable St. Simons Island Sales Experience
| Sale Benchmark | Property Type | Market Expertise |
|---|---|---|
| $2,212,000 | Luxury Estate | High-end valuation & luxury marketing |
| $1,280,000 | Primary Property | Coastal factors & Pier Village considerations |
| $1,250,000 | Golf Community Home | Neighborhood amenities & lifestyle |
| $1,000,000 | Island Residence | Retirement Relocation home acquisition |
Whether you are relocating to St. Simons Island, purchasing a primary residence, buying a vacation home, investing in Coastal Georgia real estate, or preparing to sell your property, I provide local market knowledge, professional representation, and a straightforward process designed to help you make confident real estate decisions.
Full Daily Market Report- St. Simons Island
St. Simons Island Single-Family Real Estate Market Update
Published by David Burton, Realtor® | Keller Williams Realty • October 17, 2026
Current Market Summary
The attached MLS report dated October 16, 2026 contains 198 single-family residential records for St. Simons Island, parsed line-by-line by ListingId and Status. Verbatim Status counts: Active 191, Active New Listing 3, Active Price Reduced 4, for a total of 198 active single-family. No Closed, Pending, or Cancelled statuses appear today. Median active price is $1,223,500 with average days on market 109 days and median 91 days from 192 ADOM values extracted. $850,000 and above accounts for 135 homes at 68.2% share. Entry-level single-family is $399,900 at Pelican Place, high is $11,999,000 at Point Lane. Price tier breakdown from exact price lines: Under $650,000 holds 25 homes at 13%, $650,000 to $849,999 holds 38 homes at 19%, $850,000 to $1,999,999 holds 86 homes at 43%, and $2,000,000+ holds 49 homes at 25%. New construction remains prominent with Year Built 2026 across Frederica, Ocean Road, and Kings Way corridors, plus new Driftwood Place $1,575,000 at ADOM 1.
Today's Property Movement
🆕 New Single-Family Listings Today
📉 Price Cuts Today
- Sapelo Street: Reduced to $835,000 • 104 Sapelo Street • 107 ADOM
- Vassar Point Drive: Reduced to $935,000 • 400 Vassar Point Drive • 92 ADOM
- Settlers Hammock Circle: Reduced to $750,000 • 154 Settlers Hammock Circle • 86 ADOM
- Rice Mill: Reduced to $1,095,000 • 161 Rice Mill • 51 ADOM
🔑 Closed Sale Spotlight
What the Data Means for Single-Family Buyers
With 109 days average and 4 price reductions today plus 3 fresh listings at 1 to 2 ADOM, buyers have leverage in mid-tier. Under $650,000 is scarce at 25 homes. Target new Driftwood Place $1,575,000, Yacht Club Drive $1.7M, and Saint Clair Drive $745K for fresh negotiation window. Use Sapelo Street $835K at 107 ADOM and Vassar Point Drive $935K at 92 ADOM to negotiate 2 to 3 percent below list. Waterfront and 2026 builds command premium.
What the Data Means for Single-Family Sellers
Median at $1,223,500 with 68% of inventory above $850K means luxury competition remains intense. Four price adjustments today signal sensitivity in $750K to $1,095K range. Homes priced above $1,150,000 without waterfront or 2026 build need surgical pricing to avoid 100+ DOM. Under $650K sellers hold leverage. List with pre-inspection, highlight lot over 0.2 acres, and price within 3 percent of active comps like Vassar Point Drive $935K.
Questions Buyers and Sellers Are Asking Today
Q1: How many single-family homes are currently for sale on St. Simons Island?
A: 198 active single-family homes as of October 16, 2026, parsed verbatim: Active 191, Active New Listing 3 on Driftwood Place, Yacht Club Drive, and Saint Clair Drive, and Active Price Reduced 4. Header confirms similar count. All single-family per your filter.
Q2: What is the current median list price for a single-family home on the island?
A: $1,223,500 median active price for single-family across 198 price lines. Average is higher due to Point Lane $11,999,000 anchoring ultra-luxury ceiling.
Q3: What is the entry-level price for a single-family home on St. Simons right now?
A: $399,900 at Pelican Place is lowest single-family, followed by Butler Lake Drive $455,000 and Bay Tree Court W $465,000. Only 25 homes under $650,000 representing 13% of market.
Q4: How fast are single-family homes selling on average?
A: 109 days average ADOM with median 91 days from 192 ADOM values. Fastest are 1 day for Driftwood Place $1,575,000 and Yacht Club Drive $1,700,000, and 2 days for Saint Clair Drive $745,000. Longest includes Marlin Lane $3,665,000 not in today's cuts but at 205 ADOM in prior reports.
Q5: Are new construction single-family homes readily available?
A: Yes. Multiple Year Built 2026 homes including 914 Rose Cottage Road $2.5M, 198 Ashantilly Avenue $2.59M, 1017 Ocean View Avenue $2,994,900, 4305 11th Street $3,295,990, 4217 Fourth Street $3,950,000, 106 Kings Way $4,975,000, and 21 Atlantic Point Drive $3,100,000 at 137 ADOM.
Q6: Are sellers making price adjustments to secure buyers?
A: Yes, 4 price reductions today: Sapelo Street $835,000 at 107 ADOM, Vassar Point Drive $935,000 at 92 ADOM, Settlers Hammock Circle $750,000 at 86 ADOM, and Rice Mill $1,095,000 at 51 ADOM. This is 2% of active inventory adjusting in one day, down from 10 on Oct 14.
Q7: Where is the highest-priced single-family home located on St. Simons?
A: Point Lane at $11,999,000 with 6 beds, 5 baths, 9,130 sqft on 2.13 acres, Year Built 2024, waterfront. Next is Yacht Club Lane $6,999,500 and Dixon Lane $5,999,000.
Q8: Is now a good time to list a single-family property on St. Simons Island?
A: Yes for under $850K where inventory is thin at 32% with 63 homes. For $850K+, timing is possible but pricing must be precise given 135 competitors and 4 reductions today showing buyer sensitivity around $750K to $1,095K.
Q9: Do I have leverage to negotiate in the current market?
A: Buyers have leverage on homes with ADOM over 90 days. Examples: Sapelo Street 107 ADOM $835K, Vassar Point Drive 92 ADOM $935K, Settlers Hammock Circle 86 ADOM $750K. Sellers with ADOM 1 to 2 days like Driftwood Place and Yacht Club Drive hold firm.
Q10: How do I stand out against active single-family competitors?
A: Highlight true single-family attributes: lot over 0.2 acres, waterfront YN, 2026 build status, non-HOA. In $850K to $1,999,999 tier with 86 competing homes, differentiate with pre-inspection, 2026 build certification, and pricing $15K below nearest price-reduced comp like Vassar Point Drive $935,000 or Rice Mill $1,095,000.
High-End Market Watch ($850K+ Analysis)
$850,000 (+) Single-Family Strategic Insight
The $850K+ segment holds 135 homes at 68% of single-family inventory with average 109 days. Four reductions today from $750K to $1,095K indicate price discovery in upper-middle, not ultra-luxury. Second-home buyers dominate this tier prioritizing waterfront YN, lot over 0.5 acres, and 2026 new construction. New listings Driftwood Place $1,575,000 at 0.48 acres waterfront Y and Yacht Club Drive $1,700,000 show fresh luxury entering, while Saint Clair Drive $745K provides sub-$850K opportunity. Homes like Point Lane $11.999M anchor ceiling while price cuts on Sapelo Street and Vassar Point Drive set negotiation benchmarks.
Market Interpretation: Critical Takeaways
St. Simons single-family market on October 16, 2026 shows 198 active single-family with 3 new entries at 1 to 2 ADOM averaging $1,340,000, 4 price adjustments averaging $906,250, and zero closed sales today, indicating balanced new inventory with continued price discovery. Median $1,223,500 and 68% above $850K mean sellers must price against direct single-family comps. Entry under $650K at 25 homes remains competitive, while luxury over $2M at 49 homes faces extended DOM averaging 109 days. Buyers should leverage reductions on Sapelo Street and Vassar Point Drive.
Navigating St. Simons Island Real Estate?
Get personalized single-family market analysis and strategic representation today.
Connect with David BurtonBeyond The Front Door | St. Simons $850K+ Lifestyle


